Emissions Caps: Local Law 97 Forces a Rethink
NYC Local Law 97 (part of the Climate Mobilization Act) is a landmark law targeting greenhouse gas emissions from buildings. It requires large buildings (over 25,000 sq ft) to cut carbon emissions 40% by 2030 and 80% by 2050. Starting in 2025, buildings must annually report their emissions and will face fines if they exceed the limits set for their occupancy type.
What does this mean for heating fuel? Heating oil – especially traditional No. 2 oil – produces more CO₂ per BTU of heat than natural gas. A building burning lots of oil could risk exceeding its emissions cap, especially come 2030 when limits tighten drastically.
As a result, owners of oil-heated buildings are forced to strategize: How will you get under the carbon cap? There are a few options shaping fuel plans:
- Switch to a Cleaner Fuel: Many buildings are considering converting from oil to natural gas or to dual-fuel systems (oil and gas) to reduce CO₂ output. Natural gas emits about 25–30% less CO₂ than No. 2 oil per unit of heat. Buildings that can access gas lines might plan a conversion to instantly cut emissions. Dual-fuel setups allow using gas as primary and oil as backup.
- Use Bioheat (Biodiesel Blends): Rather than ditching oil entirely, NYC is effectively cleaning oil through mandates. By law, all heating oil in NYC as of 2025 is B10 Bioheat (10% renewable biodiesel) and will be B20 (20% biodiesel) by 2030. Biodiesel is made from renewable sources and has a lower lifecycle carbon footprint. Burning B20 instead of pure fossil oil can significantly lower net CO₂ emissions. Building owners are planning to use higher biofuel blends as one compliance strategy – it doesn’t require equipment change, just buying fuel with more bio content.
- Improve Efficiency: Emissions are a function of fuel burned. If you burn less, you emit less. Thus, long-term plans include energy efficiency upgrades – like better insulation, new windows, or upgrading to high-efficiency oil burners or boilers. If you can reduce your gallon consumption each year through efficiency, you might meet targets without a fuel switch.
- Electrification: Some forward-looking plans consider partial or full electrification, such as electric heat pumps, to eliminate on-site fuel combustion emissions. While costly and challenging in older buildings, pairing a heat pump for mild weather with oil heat for the coldest days can dramatically cut fuel usage and emissions.
New York City Local Law 97 essentially means you can’t continue with the status quo if your emissions are too high. Every oil-heated building over 25,000 sq ft should be crunching the numbers on their annual CO₂ output and comparing it to current and future limits. Failing to plan means potentially massive fines, making cleaner fuel and efficiency investments the smarter long-term choice.
Heating Oil Phase-Outs: Bye-Bye No. 6 and No. 4 Oils
Even before carbon caps, NYC tackled the dirtiest heating oils through laws and regulations:
- No. 6 Oil: This heavy, tar-like oil was banned outright by NYC in 2015. Buildings had to stop using it and convert to a cleaner grade.
- No. 4 Oil: This blend of No. 6 and No. 2 oil was cleaner than No. 6 but still far dirtier than No. 2. Under New York City Local Law 32, all buildings must stop using No. 4 heating oil by July 1, 2027, with city-owned buildings facing even earlier deadlines.
This means any building still on No. 4 must have a plan now. Most will convert to No. 2 oil or Bioheat, which often requires burner adjustments and tank cleaning. Others may use the mandate as the push to complete a full oil-to-gas conversion. Converting to gas is a larger project involving new utility service and equipment, often taking many months and significant capital.
Long-term fuel planning for No. 4 users has been completely dictated by this deadline. Waiting until the last minute risks contractor shortages, higher costs, and compliance issues. Buildings that fail to convert risk losing their ability to legally operate their heating system.
The phase-out of heavy oils also improves air quality and helps with emissions compliance. For example, converting from No. 4 to No. 2 Bioheat can reduce CO₂ emissions by roughly 10% for the same heat output, while also lowering soot buildup and long-term maintenance needs.
Other Key Local Laws Influencing Fuel Planning
- Biofuel Blending Requirements: NYC and New York State require increasing biodiesel content in heating oil. By 2030, all heating oil will be at least 20% renewable. Some owners are planning to go further by using higher blends where available to dramatically cut emissions without changing equipment.
- Local Law 87 (Energy Audits & Retro-Commissioning): Required energy audits and tune-ups often uncover heating system inefficiencies. Smart owners integrate these findings into long-term fuel and capital plans.
- Local Law 84 (Benchmarking): Annual energy benchmarking creates a record of energy use over time. Owners use this data to justify fuel changes or efficiency upgrades to boards, lenders, or investors.
- NYC Gas Ban for New Buildings (Local Law 154): New construction is required to use electric heat rather than combustion-based systems. While existing buildings aren’t forced to switch, this signals the city’s long-term trajectory away from fossil fuels. Many owners are factoring this into 15–20 year planning horizons.
How Building Owners Can Strategize
- Assess Your Current Compliance Status: Determine which laws apply to your building, what fuel you’re using, and whether you’re on track for future emissions limits.
- Evaluate Fuel Options and Costs: Compare oil, Bioheat, gas, and hybrid systems. Consider both upfront conversion costs and long-term compliance savings.
- Plan Capital Upgrades with Timing: Align major system upgrades with law deadlines to avoid last-minute rushes and premium pricing.
- Work with Experts: Local law compliance planning often requires engineers, fuel experts, and filing support. Expert guidance helps avoid costly missteps.
- Monitor and Reassess: Track fuel use, emissions, and regulatory changes over time. Compliance is not a one-and-done exercise.
NYC’s energy laws add complexity to heating decisions, but they also create opportunities. Buildings that plan early often end up with cleaner, more efficient systems and lower long-term costs. The key is treating heating fuel planning as a strategic, long-term investment rather than a last-minute compliance scramble.
In short: Oil is still viable in NYC, especially when paired with Bioheat and efficiency upgrades, but it must be part of a thoughtful emissions strategy. By planning ahead, building owners can stay compliant, control costs, and keep their properties comfortable for decades to come.
Why Heating Oil Delivery Is Challenging in NYC — and How It’s Handled
Delivering heating oil to a suburban house on a wide street is one thing – delivering to a Manhattan brownstone on a narrow, parking-scarce block is another. In dense urban neighborhoods like New York City, heating oil delivery comes with unique challenges.
When Heating Oil Will Be Phased Out in NYC: The Real Timeline for Buildings
Heating oil is not being banned all at once in New York City — but it is being phased out in clear, enforceable stages. The phase-out of heating oil in NYC buildings began more than a decade ago with the elimination of the dirtiest fuel oils and continues through a series of enforceable deadlines that extend into the 2030s and beyond.